Discussion Starters for Introductory Workshop
There are two sets of thematic questions. Take 5 minutes to jot down your response(s)
to one of the questions in the first set and then discuss the responses of the group for
15 minutes. You may choose to answer any one of the questions, and the group need not
address every question in the set. Repeat the same process for the second set of
questions. Total discussion time: 40 minutes. (Note: These questions cannot adequately be
addressed in such a short time. They are good discussion starters, however, and you may
continue to ponder them and share them outside the workshop with others you know.)
First Theme: The meaning of dying
- If you had the opportunity to ask God any question about the dying process and/or death,
what would you ask? What might Gods response be to your question?
- Studies indicate that people have many fears about the dying process and death itself,
including fears about:
- Loss of control, unable to do things for oneself and to make ones own decisions
- Intolerable pain
- Isolation and loneliness
- Uselessness; the inability to be productive
- Impairment of ones mental capacity
- Being a burden to others
- Financial impact on those who are left behind
- Abandoning ones loved ones; leaving things unfinished or unresolved
- Doubt; fear of losing ones faith or most basic convictions in the face of
suffering and uncertainty
Which one or two of
these represent your greatest fear(s) and why? Any other fears? What kind of help would
you most
appreciate from others, including your family and parish, to overcome such fears?
- What positive events, interactions, or accomplishments would you like to experience if
you learned that you were dying
within six months? What steps could you take right now to begin to make such experiences
more likely?
- The Catholic Church looks at the dying process as a necessary part of life that offers a
special opportunity for
personal
and spiritual growth even in the face of death. The video mentions the following areas of
possible growth that can make dying a time of comfort and hope:
- allow and seek forgiveness
- offer thanks
- prepare for eternal life
- demonstrate love
- say good-bye, assured of greater things to come
What do you think? Are there other areas of growth or important activities you might
pursue? Does this vision of dying as a time of comfort and hope change your opinion about
the dying process in any way?
Second Theme: The dignity of life and the threat of assisted suicide
- As the video mentioned, the Catholic Church sees human life as a mystery and a gift from
God. Imagine that the subject of assisted suicide comes up in a conversation you are
having with someone who does not believe in God. How might you convince the other that
assisted suicide denies human dignity? Think of the three human-interest stories in the
video.
- The video raised several concerns about assisted suicide, including:
- Patients will lose trust in the medical profession if doctors are allowed to assist
suicides.
- Permitting assisted suicide for the dying sends the message that some people are not
wanted any more.
- Patients will be pressured to commit suicide by agencies and family members who do not
have their best interests at heart.
- The government will not be able to stop abuses.
- Assisted suicide does not respond to the true needs of the dying.
- There are positive alternatives that make assisted suicide unnecessary.
Are these valid concerns? Discuss. Think of at least one other concern that you would
raise about assisted suicide and explain why.
- The video talks about "compassionate hospice care that neither prolongs life nor
hastens death". What do you know about hospice? Can you share an experience that you
had with hospice, perhaps as a volunteer or as a relative or friend of a hospice patient?
- According to the video, the Catholic Church does not mandate the use of medical
treatment "at all costs" and permits pain medication even if the foreseen but
unintended shortening of life is a risk. Did this surprise you? Did anything else in the
video come as a surprise? Discuss.