Those who voted yes ("Y") favored the amendment. The second vote was on the question of whether to pass the main bill. The bill was passed without the amendment by a vote of 140 to 16. Those who voted no ("N") opposed the bill. Those who did not vote are marked as "X".
Please note that some legislators are listed more than once because their district boundaries include more than one diocese. Information provided by the Massachusetts Catholic Conference.
| Diocese | Last Name | First Name | Broaden Religious Exemption | Mandate Contraceptive Coverage |
| Boston | (Cresta) | Open Seat. | ||
| Atkins | Cory | N | Y | |
| Ayers | Bruce J. | N | Y | |
| Balser | Ruth B. | N | Y | |
| Barrios | Jarrett | N | Y | |
| Blumer | Deborah | N | Y | |
| Bradley | Garrett | X | X | |
| Broadhurst | Arthur J. | Y | Y | |
| Brown | Scott P. | Y | Y | |
| Cahill | Michael P. | N | Y | |
| Canavan | Christine E. | N | Y | |
| Carron | Mark J. | Y | N | |
| Casey | Paul C. | N | Y | |
| Ciampa | Vincent P. | Y | Y | |
| Cleven | Carol C. | N | Y | |
| Connolly | Edward G. | Y | N | |
| Coppola | Michael | Y | Y | |
| Creedon | Geraldine | Y | Y | |
| DeLeo | Robert A. | N | Y | |
| DeMacedo | Vinny M. | Y | Y | |
| Demakis | Paul C. | N | Y | |
| Dempsey | Brian S. | N | Y | |
| DiMasi | Salvatore F. | N | Y | |
| Donato | Paul | Y | Y | |
| Donnelly | David T. | Y | N | |
| Donovan | Carol A. | N | Y | |
| Fagan | James H. | N | Y | |
| Fallon | Christopher G. | N | Y | |
| Falzone | Mark | N | Y | |
| Fennell | Robert F. | N | Y | |
| Festa | Michael E. | N | Y | |
| Finneran | Thomas M. | Y | N | |
| Fitzgerald | Kevin W. | N | Y | |
| Flynn | David L. | Y | Y | |
| Fox | Gloria L. | N | Y | |
| Galvin | William C. | Y | Y | |
| Garry | Colleen M. | Y | N | |
| Golden | Brian P. | X | X | |
| Golden Jr. | Thomas A. | Y | Y | |
| Greene | William G. | Y | Y | |
| Hall | Geoffrey D. | N | Y | |
| Hargraves | Robert S. | N | Y | |
| Harkins | Lida E. | N | Y | |
| Hart Jr. | John A. | Y | Y | |
| Hill | Bradford R. | N | Y | |
| Honan | Kevin G. | N | Y | |
| Hynes | Frank M. | N | Y | |
| Jehlen | Patricia D. | N | Y | |
| Jones | Bradley H. | Y | Y | |
| Kafka | Louis L. | N | Y | |
| Kaprielian | Rachel | N | Y | |
| Kaufman | Jay R. | N | Y | |
| Kennedy | Thomas P. | Y | N | |
| Khan | Kay S. | N | Y | |
| Koutoujian | Peter J. | N | Y | |
| LeDuc | Stephen P. | N | Y | |
| Lewis | Maryanne | N | Y | |
| Linsky | David Paul | N | Y | |
| Locke | John A. | N | Y | |
| Loscocco | Paul | Y | Y | |
| Malia | Elizabeth A. | N | Y | |
| Mariano | Ronald | N | Y | |
| Marini | Francis L. | Y | Y | |
| Marzilli Jr. | J. James | N | Y | |
| McGee | Thomas M. | N | Y | |
| Miceli | James R. | Y | Y | |
| Murphy | Kevin J. | Y | Y | |
| Murphy | James M. | N | Y | |
| Murphy | Charles A. | N | Y | |
| Nangle | David M. | Y | Y | |
| Nyman | Robert J. | Y | Y | |
| O'Brien | Thomas J. | N | Y | |
| O'Flaherty | Eugene L. | Y | Y | |
| Owens-Hicks | Shirley | N | Y | |
| Patrick | Matthew | N | Y | |
| Paulsen | Anne M. | N | Y | |
| Petersen | Douglas W. | N | Y | |
| Petruccelli | Anthony | N | Y | |
| Poirier | Elizabeth A. | Y | N | |
| Pope | Susan W. | N | Y | |
| Provost | Ruth W. | N | Y | |
| Reinstein | Kathi-Anne | N | Y | |
| Rogers | John H. | Y | Y | |
| Ruane | J. Michael | Y | N | |
| Rushing | Byron | N | Y | |
| Santiago | Jose L. | N | Y | |
| Scaccia | Angelo M. | Y | N | |
| Slattery | John P. | N | Y | |
| Smizik | Frank Israel | N | Y | |
| Speliotis | Theodore C. | N | Y | |
| Spilka | Karen | N | Y | |
| St. Fleur | Marie | N | Y | |
| Stanley | Thomas M. | Y | Y | |
| Stanley | Harriett L. | N | Y | |
| Sullivan | Joseph C. | N | Y | |
| Teahan | Kathleen M. | N | Y | |
| Timilty | Walter F. | Y | N | |
| Tirone | Paul E. | N | Y | |
| Tobin | A. Stephen | Y | N | |
| Toomey Jr. | Timothy J. | Y | Y | |
| Torrisi | David M. | N | Y | |
| Vallee | James E. | N | Y | |
| Verga | Anthony J. | N | Y | |
| Walrath | Patricia A. | N | Y | |
| Walsh | Martin J. | N | Y | |
| Wolf | Alice K. | N | Y | |
| Fall River | Atsalis | Demetrius | N | Y |
| Cabral | Antonio F.D. | N | Y | |
| Correia | Robert | Y | Y | |
| Creedon | Geraldine | Y | Y | |
| Fagan | James H. | N | Y | |
| Flynn | David L. | Y | Y | |
| George | Thomas N. | N | Y | |
| Gomes | Shirley A. | N | Y | |
| Haddad | Patricia | N | Y | |
| Koczera | Robert M. | N | Y | |
| Lepper | John A. | Y | Y | |
| Patrick | Matthew | N | Y | |
| Poirier | Elizabeth A. | Y | N | |
| Provost | Ruth W. | N | Y | |
| Quinn | John F. | N | Y | |
| Rodrigues | Michael J. | Y | Y | |
| Rogers | George | Y | N | |
| Straus | William M. | N | Y | |
| Sullivan | David B. | Y | Y | |
| Travis | Philip | N | Y | |
| Turkington | Eric T. | N | Y | |
| Springfield | (Nagle Jr.) | Open Seat | ||
| Asselin | Christopher | Y | Y | |
| Bosley | Daniel | N | Y | |
| Buoniconti | Stephen | Y | Y | |
| Candaras | Gale D. | N | Y | |
| Caron | Paul E. | N | Y | |
| Finegold | Barry R. | N | Y | |
| Flavin | Nancy | N | Y | |
| Hahn | Cele | N | Y | |
| Hillman | Reed V. | Y | Y | |
| Hodgkins | Christopher J. | N | Y | |
| Kane | Michael | N | Y | |
| Keenan | Daniel F. | N | Y | |
| Kelly | Shaun P. | N | Y | |
| Kulik | Stephen | N | Y | |
| Larkin | Peter J. | Y | Y | |
| Merrigan | John F. | N | Y | |
| Petrolati | Thomas M. | Y | Y | |
| Rivera | Cheryl | N | Y | |
| Rogeness | Mary S. | N | Y | |
| Story | Ellen | N | Y | |
| Swan | Benjamin | N | Y | |
| Wagner | Joseph F. | Y | Y | |
| Worcester | Binienda | John J. | Y | N |
| Bunker | David C. | N | Y | |
| Carron | Mark J. | Y | N | |
| Fresolo | John P. | Y | N | |
| Frost | Paul K. | Y | Y | |
| Gobi | Anne M. | N | Y | |
| Goguen | Emile J. | N | N | |
| Hall | Geoffrey D. | N | Y | |
| Hargraves | Robert S. | N | Y | |
| Hillman | Reed V. | Y | Y | |
| Knuuttila | Brian | N | Y | |
| Kujawski | Paul | Y | N | |
| Kulik | Stephen | N | Y | |
| Leary | James Brendan | N | Y | |
| LeDuc | Stephen P. | N | Y | |
| Loscocco | Paul | Y | Y | |
| Naughton Jr. | Harold P. | N | Y | |
| Parente | Marie J. | N | Y | |
| Pedone | Vincent A. | N | Y | |
| Peterson Jr. | George N. | Y | Y | |
| Polito | Karyn | N | Y | |
| Simmons | Mary Jane | N | Y | |
| Spellane | Robert | N | Y | |
| Vallee | James E. | N | Y | |